La Tavola

Nestled in the heart of Sayville, NY, La Tavola offers an authentic taste of Italy that beckons both casual diners and passionate food lovers alike. This Italian restaurant and takeout spot masterfully blends tradition with contemporary flair, crafting dishes that tantalize the palate and warm the soul.

La Tavola’s menu is an invitation to savor Italy’s rich culinary heritage. Start your meal with small plates like the Crispy Parmesan Herb Chicken Wings, perfectly paired with a creamy Gorgonzola black pepper dip that delivers a delightful balance of crispy, tangy, and smooth flavors. The Arancini, stuffed generously with savory sausage and melted Provolone and served with a vibrant marinara, are a must-try that transport you straight to southern Italy. Of course, no visit is complete without diving into the Grandma D’s Meatballs — tender, seasoned beef simmered in rich marinara and topped with Parmesan — a dish that customers rave about for its heartwarming, homemade taste.

For those who seek lighter fare, the fresh and crisp salads like the Fig Salad—with braised figs, pears, prosciutto, almonds, and Gorgonzola dressed in a luscious port wine vinaigrette—offer a perfect harmony of sweet and savory. Or indulge in the Mesclun Greens Salad, brightened by grape tomatoes and red onion, and dressed with a tangy balsamic vinaigrette.

Pizza lovers will find themselves spellbound by the Neapolitan Brick Oven Pizzas. The Margherita Pizza is a classic masterpiece boasting San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, and fragrant basil, while the Melanzana Pizza brings together breaded eggplant, creamy ricotta, and mozzarella layered atop brick oven-roasted tomatoes for an earthy, comforting experience. For those adventurous enough, the Hot Honey & Pepperoni Pie delivers a spicy-sweet kick with chili-infused honey perfectly complementing the pepperoni and mozzarella.

The dining atmosphere at La Tavola echoes the warmth and charm of a traditional Italian trattoria. Guests frequently mention the cozy interior and inviting veranda seating, where natural light frames vibrant conversations and leisurely meals. Whether you’re celebrating a special milestone like a wedding anniversary or simply indulging in a well-deserved lunch, the ambiance enhances the entire culinary journey.

Beyond the food, the service shines with genuine attentiveness and professionalism—an aspect repeatedly praised by patrons like Stephen Powers, who admires the “perfect atmosphere” paired with great service. Leslie Volle sums it up beautifully, highlighting not only the food but also the exceptional bread that arrives steaming hot and with a delightfully crisp crust, a small yet unforgettable flourish that speaks volumes about La Tavola’s dedication to quality.

From delightful appetizers to hearty mains, and crafty cocktails that add the perfect finishing touch, La Tavola is more than just a restaurant—it’s an experience. Whether you’re savoring the ravioli with fig and prosciutto or indulging in the best tartufo you’ve ever tasted, every bite is a celebration of flavor and passion.

For those in Sayville or visitors seeking an authentic Italian dining experience that melds exceptional food with warm hospitality, La Tavola stands out as a destination you’ll want to return to again and again.